Every time I do Jack Kirby Tribute Month (as I recently did), it requires me to go back and look at Kirby’s work again. It’s never a chore or a hardship. An interesting thing I’ve discovered is that Jack often takes what might be called an “impressionistic” approach to his costume designs. Specific details can tend to shift from issue to issue, even panel to panel. You don’t notice it until you have to take a more analytical look for things like Jack Kirby Tribute Month.
One step even further are the characters whose appearance shifts even more drastically and deliberately. Odin in Journey into Mystery/Thor was like this. Jack would give him completely different outfits almost every time he appeared, even within the same issue! And I discovered that Hela was another character whose look changed a lot. She appeared in a total of four issues during Jack’s run, and each time she looked different.
Hela first appeared in a “Tales of Asgard” backup in Journey into Mystery #102. The young Thor bargained with her for the life of Sif. This was also Sif’s first appearance, and she looked very different from how she would later appear when she became a regular supporting character in the main stories. Just for fun, I included that original version of Sif here.
Hela’s second appearance was in Thor #133, also in a “Tales of Asgard” backup. Note that in this version, she has a giant collar, and the “horn” elements seen earlier have now become attached to it instead of to her head. This time, she’s accompanied by a troop of Valkyries. In this short tale, the reader gets to see Hela and her Valkyries conduct a recently-deceased hero on to Valhalla.
Hela’s third appearance during Jack’s JIM/Thor run is in Thor #150. This one is a significant appearance. Not only is she cover-featured, it’s also her first appearance in one of the main stories instead of the backups. Plus this is the look that ultimately became her default. The collar vanishes from this version, and the “horns” are once more attached to Hela’s head.
Jack’s fourth and final shot at drawing Hela was only four months later, in Thor #154. In this story, once again Hela is about to lay claim to Sif. It’s probably the wildest design of them all: a giant collar and mantle, with big “horns” attached to both the collar and Hela’s head.
Though there are certain consistent elements to all these versions, how they’re configured each time changes. And that’s not all on Jack, because obviously the colorists were being creative each time too. I’ve been thinking about why Jack might’ve chosen to draw Hela differently each time, trying to reason it out. I have no inside creative knowledge here, but it seems like he could’ve been thinking that death is different for everyone, and hence Hela’s appearance might be different in each situation.
I also am curious as to why, instead of using Jack’s last version of her from Thor #154 as her default look, Marvel went with her earlier Thor #150 appearance. Perhaps it’s as simple as they just forgot about Thor #154, and since she appeared on the cover of Thor #150, they knew she was there. So they just defaulted to that version.
Anyway, as I was working on Hela for this year’s Jack Kirby Tribute Month, I thought it might be fun to do a little study into all these looks and compare them. You might even argue there’s a fifth, as she appears as part of an elaborate montage of characters on the cover of Thor #154. But I decided not to count it, since that design isn’t all that far removed from her Thor #150 design. Plus everything in the montage is knocked in in pale green, so there are no color cues.
Hope you enjoyed this little study!























































